I was excited when I got my email today with VIP invite!
Signup was super-easy, and getting to the web player was easy since I already use Chrome. I may install the desktop and mobile apps at some point, but for now I'm just using the web player.
The reason I want to try this is to find out if it can replace Spotify in my life. The sound quality of Spotify is not great, but I mainly use it for finding new music and deciding if I want to buy it. I also use it if I'm stuck in a waiting room. If this is like Spotify but with good sound quality, I'll be happy.
Here are my first impressions:
Browsed around for a few obscure artists to see what the music selection looks like. Tons of Bill Frisell, so that's a good sign. Let's take a quick glance and see what else we can find:
Trio Pim Jacobs: Wow, can't believe they have that! I had to order that CD from Japan.
Nektar: Obscure prog-rock, can't believe they have it.
Talk Talk: Surprised they have it.
Stereolab: Not everything available, but quite a bit.
Guthrie Govan: Hmm...only one album.
Crowded House: Yep
Pekka Pohjola: A few albums, missing my favorite one (Harakka Bialoipokku)
Philip Glass: Some, not a lot. One thing I noticed is that they have the "real" original Koyaanisqatsi soundtrack, and not the re-recorded one or the horrible "complete soundtrack" version. Nice!
How about something more common:
Beatles: Not very much. None of their studio albums.
Steely Dan: Missing a few of their studio albums, but a decent selection...
Miles Davis: Tons
Led Zeppelin: Yep
Pink Floyd: Lots (I think it's all the studio albums)
King Crimson: nothing
Yes: Lots
Rush: Yep
Metallica: Nope
Iron Maiden: Nope
Daft Punk: Yep
Phish: Lots, including live stuff
It seems like the selection varies quite a bit. I will spend some more time exploring when I get home tonight and can really focus on it.
Let's take a listen. I'm at work, and my work PC is nothing special. I'm just using onboard sound and some old Sony MDR-V600 headphones. I typically use JRiver Media Center at work, and listen to FLAC files. It sounds good. Not as good as listening to my HiFi at home, but it gets me through the days.
How does Tidal sound? The first song I listened to, by the Trio Pim Jacobs sounds "grainy" to me. My FLAC files in JRiver are as smooth as silk, no grain at all. I wonder where Tidal got their files. My CD is a Japanese remaster.
Let's try comparing something else. Dave Matthews Band, Ants Marching. Sounds spot-on. Can't tell a difference between my FLAC files in JRMC and what Tidal is playing.
How about Nickel Creek's Elephant in the Corn? I think I might hear a very slight difference in the EQ. A little rolled off the high end. I'll have to check that out on the HiFi at home.
There's much more comparing to do, but that will have to wait until I get home tonight.
More to come.